Can you please advice on my MF portfolio?

Q & A ForumCategory: InvestmentsCan you please advice on my MF portfolio?
KumarG_007 asked 8 years ago
Hello Sreekanth, Thank you for providing this platform for gaining personal finance knowledge and understanding it. I have invested in Mutual Funds in three different portfolio started couples of year back and having some questions: —————————————————————————————————————————————————— Portfolio#1: Child Education (30000 monthly) —————————————————————————————————————————————————— 1. ICICI Pru Value Discovery (G) – 12000 (monthly) 2. Franklin India Prima Plus (G) – 12000 (monthly) 3. DSPBR Income Opportunities Fund -Reg(G) – 6000 (monthly) —————————————————————————————————————————————————— Portfolio#2: Child Marriage (30000 monthly) —————————————————————————————————————————————————— 1. UTI Equity fund (G) – 20000 (monthly) 2. Birla SL Dynamic Bond fund-Reg(G) – 5000 (monthly) 3. ICICI Pru Flexible Income Plan(G) – 5000 (monthly) ——————————————————————————————————————————————————Portfolio#3: Retirement (40000 monthly) —————————————————————————————————————————————————— 1. Franklin India Bluechip (G) – 15000 (monthly) 2. HDFC Mid-Cap Opportunities fund (G) – 15000 (monthly) 2. Birla Sunlife Floating Rate Fund-Long Term Plan (G) – 10000 (monthly) —————————————————————————————————————————————————— Other NON-ACTIVE SIP  —————————————————————————————————————————————————— 1. HDFC Equity (SIP stopped since 2013 but not redeemed) 2. SBI Emerging Business fund (SIP stopped since 2013 but not redeemed) Note: —————————————— 1. All these investments are for long term (more than 10 years) 2. All these portfolio having 75%-25% (Equity and Debt ratio) Few Questions: —————————————— 1. I noticed that UTI Equity fund is not performing well from long time so is it time to replace this fund with other performing fund like: – ICICI Pru Focused Bluechip, or – SBI Bluechip – Marie India Opportunities fund What is your recommendation here? 2. Regarding HDFC Equity & SBI emerging Business fund (non-active SIP), actually I had a plan to redeem the units and invest into existing funds via STP mode, but I noticed that from past few months these funds are performing really well as profit of HDFC equity only increased to 30k in just 3 months so now confused whether should I redeem it now or wait for some more time. What’s your suggestion here? 3. Any other suggestions or improvement areas in my all three portfolio? I shall be grateful for your prompt suggestions/response. Thanks in advance, Kumar!
7 Answers
Sreekanth Staff answered 8 years ago
Dear Kumar, 1 - Any specific reason for not picking mid/small cap funds though your investment time-frame is 10 years? 2 - Your view on having two debt funds for Child marriage goal portfolio? 3 - Yes, UTI Equity fund can be replaced by any other Large cap / Diversified equity fund.  Birla Frontline / ICICI Focused etc., (large cap) can be considered. 4 - HDFC Equity / SBI emerging bluechp : These are good funds.. classic example of benefit of not churning your portfolio. You may continue with your investments. Related articles; https://www.relakhs.com/best-mutual-fund-scheme-risk-ratios/ https://www.relakhs.com/mutual-fund-portfolio-overlap-comparison-tools/ https://www.relakhs.com/200-day-moving-average-dma-mutual-funds/
KumarG_007 answered 8 years ago
Dear Sreekanth Thank you for reponse. 1 – No specific reason for not picking mid/small cap funds, can you please suggest some good funds and advantage of adding it? Just for my understanding and learning purpose. 2 – Regarding 2 debt funds in Child marriage portfolio, actually I had plan to accumalate amount for yearly PPF payment that's why choosen two debt funds. These funds are completing year in Aug 2018. 3 – Thanks, I will replace UTI Equity fund with your suggested funds. 4 – So whats your sugggestion for HDFC Equity / SBI emerging bluechp, should I continue holding it and should not go for redeeemtion of units but until how long?
Please note that these are not active SIP. Regards,
Kumar!
Sreekanth Staff answered 8 years ago
Dear Kumar, 1 - As your investment time-frame is long-term, you may include mid-cap fund to your portfolio(s).  Ex : HDFC Mid-cap opp fund / Franklin Prima etc., 2 - You mean to say that you would like to redeem the units of these two debt funds and then re-invest the proceeds in PPF? 4 - You may continue holding on to them as long as they provide decent returns visa vis their category avg returns and/or benchmark indices.  
KumarG_007 replied 8 years ago

Dear Sreekanth,

1. I already have HDFC Mid-cap opp fund in my portfolio, okay I will add one at least in each portfolio I have.

2. Yes that was my plan to pay PPF yearly amount from the redeem units.

4. Okay

Apart from this, based on your other suggestions I will modify my current portfolio and will ask you for further review.

Thanks!

KumarG_007 replied 8 years ago

Hi Sreekanth,

Based on your suggestion and few more consideration, I am in the final stage of reshuffling my portfolio and I need your suggestion again on my SIP portfolio review.

I am thinking to create a diversified portfolio for each goal which contain mix of Large cap, Multi-
cap, Mid-small cap and a Debt fund.

I want to go for 75% ~ 25% equity-debt ratio overall.

Hence I have chosen some new funds (from missed funds category) as highlighted as NEW below:

PORTFOLIO – Retirement
1. Franklin India Bluechip Fund(G) (EQUITY-Large Cap, 10000 per month)
2. ICICI Pru Value Discovery Fund(G) (EQUITY-Multi Cap, 7000 per month)
3. HDFC Mid-Cap Opportunities Fund(G) (EQUITY-Mid Cap, 15000 per month)
4. Birla SL FRF-Long Term Plan(G) (DEBT, 8000 per month)

PORTFOLIO – Child Marriage
1. ICICI Pru Bluechip Fund (EQUITY-Large Cap, 10000 per month) ………NEW
2. SBI Magnum Multi Cap (EQUITY-Multi Cap, 7000 per month) ………NEW
3. Franklin India Smaller Companies (EQUITY-Mid-Small Cap, 7000 per month) ………NEW
4. DSPBR Income Opportunities Fund-Reg(G) (DEBT, 6000 per month)

PORTFOLIO – Child Education
1. SBI Bluechip (EQUITY-Large Cap, 10000 per month) ………NEW
2. Franklin India Prima Plus Fund(G) (EQUITY-Multi Cap, 7000 per month)
3. Mirae Asset Emerging Bluechip Fund (EQUITY-Mid-Small Cap, 7000 per month) ………NEW
4. ICICI Pru Flexible Income Plan(G) (DEBT Cap, 6000 per month)

Could you please suggest following:
1. My thinking of mix of funds in each category for each portfolio is required now and good to go?

2. Is the amount allocation between each fund category is okay or any correction required? Please note my all goals are 10+ years away.

3. Is my any of funds/portfolio is overlapped?

4. The newly selected funds are good enough or is there any better options?

Seeking for your valuable feedback on above.

BR,
Kumar!

Sreekanth Staff answered 8 years ago
Dear Kumar, Individually all the listed funds are good ones. Suggest you to kindly go through the first two links (articles) that I have shared in my previous answer (especially the overlap one).
KumarG_007 replied 8 years ago

Hi Sreekanth,

Since market is down now a days, so is it advisable to do additional top-up of some of the existing funds?

If yes, can you suggest which fund should I choose for one-time top-up investment just to take advantage of market fall?

Thanks,
Kumar

Sreekanth Staff replied 8 years ago

Dear Kumar,
Given a choice, I would make additional investments in Diversified equity funds or Mid/Small cap funds now for my long-term goals. Or Even in ELSS funds for accumulation + tax saving.

KumarG_007 replied 8 years ago

Dear Sreekanth,

Hope you are fine and doing well.

I am in the process of re-shuffling my portfolio for setting proper asset allocation between Equity and Debt fund. Presently I have investment in below 4 debts funds (apart from Equity funds) but I want you suggestion on following points:

1) Since my all investments are for long term (7+ years), are these 4 existing debts funds (mentioned below) are right choice for debts funds for long term prospective? If No then can you please suggest which one should I replace and by which fund?

My current Debt funds:
> Aditya Birla SL FRF-Long Term Plan(G) (Active SIP)
> ICICI Pru Savings Fund(G) (Active SIP)
> DSP Credit Risk Fund-Reg(G) (Active SIP)
> Aditya Birla SL Dynamic Bond Fund-Reg(G) (IN-Active SIP)

Please note,
> I wanted to invest in only 3 debts fund for long term prospective (1 for each portfolio, total 3).
> I have some investment in FD
> I have some investment in PPF (but not much)

2) I am going for below allocation percentage for different fund categories, is that advisable or any correction required?

Equity: 70%
Larger Cap: 60%
Mid-cap/small cap: 20
Multi-cap: 20
Debt: 30%

Awaiting for your prompt response.

BR,
Kumar

KumarG_007 answered 8 years ago
Dear Sreekanth, Hope you are fine and doing well. I am in the process of re-shuffling my portfolio for setting proper asset allocation between Equity and Debt fund. Presently I have investment in below 4 debts funds (apart from Equity funds) but I want you suggestion on following points: 1) Since my all investments are for long term (7+ years), are these 4 existing debts funds (mentioned below) are right choice for debts funds for long term prospective? If No then can you please suggest which one should I replace and by which fund? My current Debt funds:
> Aditya Birla SL FRF-Long Term Plan(G) (Active SIP)
> ICICI Pru Savings Fund(G) (Active SIP)
> DSP Credit Risk Fund-Reg(G) (Active SIP)
> Aditya Birla SL Dynamic Bond Fund-Reg(G) (IN-Active SIP) Please note,
> I wanted to invest in only 3 debts fund for long term prospective (1 for each portfolio, total 3).
> I have some investment in FD
> I have some investment in PPF (but not much) 2) I am going for below allocation percentage for different fund categories, is that advisable or any correction required? Equity: 70%
Larger Cap: 60%
Mid-cap/small cap: 20
Multi-cap: 20
Debt: 30% Awaiting for your prompt response. BR,
Kumar
Sreekanth Staff answered 8 years ago
Dear Kumar, May I know what do you mean by 70% Equity? Are you referring to direct Equities (Shares)?? Are you employed and contribute to EPF Scheme?  
KumarG_007 replied 8 years ago

Hi Sreekanth,

Thanks for your reply.

1) By 70% Equity, I meant Equity mutual funds (investment in Larger cap, multi-cap, mid-small cap mutual funds), Let me elaborate my details.

Currently I am investing 100,000 monthly via SIP in 3 different portfolios of Mutual funds. Each portfolio having mix of equity and debt mutual funds (details are available in my previous posts of this questions).

Now while doing mid-term review, I observe that the fund allocation between Equity and debt mutual funds is not proper, so I wanted to reshuffle my portfolio with 70~75% equity mutual funds and 25~30% in debt mutual funds.

Hence I am seeking your suggestions on my existing debts mutual funds, whether it is good to continue with these funds for long term (7+ years) prospective or should I replace with any other better long term debt funds (please refer my previous post for existing debt funds)

Apart from this, I do have separate investment in direct stocks, but its very little.

2) No, I don’t have EPF scheme as currently I am working aboard and my EPF account is suspended.

But, this brings me another question related to NRI investment, I will ask in a separate questions as I want to close this topic first.

Because of turning into NRI, I have holed my investment in PPF, so for debt side I only have SIP in debt mutual funds (apart from few FD).

Kindly suggest further.

BR,
Kumar

Sreekanth Staff answered 8 years ago
Dear Kumar, Actually PPF can be the first choice under debt category. But, there was a policy flip-flop with regards to NRIs investments in PPF by the Govt.  Related Article :  Latest NSC & PPF rules for Non-Resident Indians (NRIs) | New Amendments to PPF Act & NSC Debt Funds : As your investment horizon is long-term, you may look at avenues like Debt Hybrid Funds, Floating rate funds, Dynamic Debt Funds etc., You can also have a look at Secured NCD Issues which are open for NRIs as well (may be for 5 year time-frame). In case, we get new Tax-Free Bond issues in the future, you may also consider investing in them. Your Funds - > Aditya Birla SL FRF-Long Term Plan(G) &  Aditya Birla SL Dynamic Bond Fund-Reg(G)  are decent choices for long term. The other two funds are Short-term oriented (Low duration). May not be a good choice for long term. You can also have a look at Debt Hyrbid funds (erstwhile known as MIP funds). For ex : ICICI Regular Savings Fund.    
KumarG_007 replied 8 years ago

Hi Sreekanth,

Thanks again.

Can you also suggest on below allocation percentage for different fund categories for a long term portfolio (7+ years) , is that advisable or any correction required?

Equity: 70~75%
Larger Cap: 60%
Mid-cap/small cap: 20
Multi-cap: 20
Debt: 25~30%

Sreekanth Staff replied 8 years ago

Hi..The asset allocation is ok as of now, but you may have to review your portfolio and go for portfolio re-balancing as you approach your Goal target year(s).

KumarG_007 replied 8 years ago

Thank you!

Scroll to Top
Secret Link