STP vs SIP

Dipa asked 10 years ago
Hello sir, I have just discovered something about my SIP I just compared my SIPs with SIP from Saving account VS  STP 5 funds comparisons SBI Bluechip SBI mag gloabal SBI mag Equity SBI mag Balanced SBI mag Mid cap SIP of 2k for each fund since OCT 2015 total investment = 1,80,000 (36k for each fund ) current value = 2,01,057.05 SIP installment deduct from my savings account (I have lump sum in savings account) now after reading your article "Is creating wealth through Systematic Investment Plan (SIP) a hoax?" and knowing the STP investment i have just discover the result : If i would have invested this through STP rout then i would get double benefits from two funds. If I would have invested this 180000 in SBI Magnum Monthly Income Plan  Floater then the return would be 2,18,337 instead of 2,01,057 Correct me if i am wrong what i have learned about this. Thank you !
3 Answers
Sreekanth Staff answered 10 years ago
Hi, In your earlier Question, you have mentioned that you have 8 SIPs and now 5 SIPs, may I know if you are asking queries on behalf of any other individuals ? May I know reason for choosing only SBI MF Schemes? If you have to do comparative analysis then kindly do it for same set of funds both for SIP & STP :) (Request you to post your queries on SIPs, STPs or MFs here in this thread itself, instead of posting new Questions, thank you!)  
Dipa answered 10 years ago
Hello sir When i started mf investments i started from SBI & they suggest me to choose their funds only in 2015 But today i m doing SIP of 20k (as mentioned in prev que) and stopped sbi global and sbi balanced from my portfolio and added new ones. But for comparison purpose i just compare 5 funds of sbi of my portfolio & found this result
Sreekanth Staff answered 10 years ago
Hi, You may kindly trim down your portfolio a bit. Do not worry too much about SIP Vs STP. Opt for a route/mode which is comfortable to you and let the funds grow. Keep a track of your portfolio once in a while :)
Scroll to Top
Secret Link