STP vs SIP

Dipa asked 9 years ago
Hello sir, I have just discovered something about my SIP I just compared my SIPs with SIP from Saving account VS  STP 5 funds comparisons SBI Bluechip SBI mag gloabal SBI mag Equity SBI mag Balanced SBI mag Mid cap SIP of 2k for each fund since OCT 2015 total investment = 1,80,000 (36k for each fund ) current value = 2,01,057.05 SIP installment deduct from my savings account (I have lump sum in savings account) now after reading your article "Is creating wealth through Systematic Investment Plan (SIP) a hoax?" and knowing the STP investment i have just discover the result : If i would have invested this through STP rout then i would get double benefits from two funds. If I would have invested this 180000 in SBI Magnum Monthly Income Plan  Floater then the return would be 2,18,337 instead of 2,01,057 Correct me if i am wrong what i have learned about this. Thank you !
3 Answers
Sreekanth Staff answered 9 years ago
Hi, In your earlier Question, you have mentioned that you have 8 SIPs and now 5 SIPs, may I know if you are asking queries on behalf of any other individuals ? May I know reason for choosing only SBI MF Schemes? If you have to do comparative analysis then kindly do it for same set of funds both for SIP & STP :) (Request you to post your queries on SIPs, STPs or MFs here in this thread itself, instead of posting new Questions, thank you!)  
Dipa answered 9 years ago
Hello sir When i started mf investments i started from SBI & they suggest me to choose their funds only in 2015 But today i m doing SIP of 20k (as mentioned in prev que) and stopped sbi global and sbi balanced from my portfolio and added new ones. But for comparison purpose i just compare 5 funds of sbi of my portfolio & found this result
Sreekanth Staff answered 9 years ago
Hi, You may kindly trim down your portfolio a bit. Do not worry too much about SIP Vs STP. Opt for a route/mode which is comfortable to you and let the funds grow. Keep a track of your portfolio once in a while :)
Scroll to Top
Secret Link